Pam Alison Knits

These are the voyages of a wordy, woolly, inky Aquarian


Is it a bag? Is it a planner?

Here is something I saw on my recent travels and I think you can see why I was captivated by it. This was part of a display at Harewood House in Yorkshire and it was owned by Princess Mary, Princess of Wales and Countess of Harewood.

At first, from the top, it looks very much like a vintage Filofax, then you notice the chain and you wonder, is it a bag? Viewed edge-on it reveals a framed “purse” within the cover, very much in keeping with the built-in purses I’ve seen in handbags from the mid-20th century. But look closely and rather than a ring mechanism holding pages such as you’d see in a Filofax, this has elastic to hold the notebooks in place. So, it’s a form of Traveller’s Notebook. The side view shows a nice slim pen or pencil slotted behind the strap closure. As it is displayed with booklets from Royal Ascot, I presume it was primarily used at race meetings rather than being an “everyday carry”.

How intriguing.

The Traveller’s Notebook that stationery fans are familiar with nowadays started to appear in 2006. I must admit, I’d assumed it was a new idea – a way to get around the inconveniences of ring-planners whilst retaining some of the flexibility. Seems there’s nothing new about it at all.

I seem to recall that Franklin Covey (the USA equivalent of the British Filofax) added a shoulder strap to a ring-planner cover many years ago, and this is slightly reminiscent of that as well.

I must admit that I envy the clasp purse section most of all. Imagine if our Filofaxes had such a thing. Yes, it would make writing on the left-hand page a nightmare, but the romance of it!

The Traveller’s Notebook is a format I’ve never tried myself. Although many avow to it being more practical than ring systems, there are a few things which put me off. First, Travellers Notebook covers tend to just be a single thickness of leather and to my mind that equals floppy. Second, I watch people showing their covers with two or three notebooks in place, and they just look like they’d be even less easy to write in than a ring planner. Again, elastics just say floppy to me – if the notebooks are going to move even a little bit then I don’t want to know.

So, I’d never want this item for myself (which is fortunate, because I don’t think there can be many around). For interest, though, it’s well worth a look.



3 responses to “Is it a bag? Is it a planner?”

  1. Pam,

    Very interesting article! Fascinating combination – bespoke?

    Having used Travelers Notebook (Regular) full time for over a and part time for 2/3 more I would the major advantage of the Travelers Notebook is portability 210mm high so full A5 by 110mm wide narrower than 148mm (A5) which puts slight space constraint depending how configure it. A large variety inserts available that cover most people’s needs – Diaries tend to be 6 months whether vertical or week on onside and notes/space on the other. Really enjoyed using it but have gone back, for now, to full size A5 6 ring binder with 13/14mm rings (Lochby A5 Field Binder) and so far so good. When the Filofax Flex came out (some time ago) I used it with a Flex notebook slipped into the left (front) cover and a moleskine soft cover weekly planner slipped into the back cover with a pen loop that came on a slip in card. I found this arrangement really good and used it for years. I switched from moleskine to leuchturm because, by their own admission, moleskine paper did not handle ink well and I was moving back to fountain pens for writing with.

    The main issue for many with the Travelers Notebook is not being able to move pages around as you are using bound tomoe river inserts (fantastic with ink!).

    Charles

    1. Hi, Charles. Very interested in your description of your various notebooks. I think, considering the aristocratic status of the owner, this would have been custom-made and probably specific to use at race meetings. I visited some more stately homes over the past week and was interested in the notebooks on display in a couple of them showing that some of the owners were keeping diaries/journals of their lives.

  2. […] Is it a bag? Is it a planner? – Pam Alison Knits […]

I’d love to hear from you, please feel free to leave a comment.